facebook   linkedin   goodreads    Buy the Book
  • Home
  • Authors
    • Sister Authors
    • Meet Leslie
    • Meet Meryll
  • Book
    • About the Book
    • Discussion Questions
    • Beyond the Pale
    • Behind the Scenes
    • More about the Dedication Page
    • Reviews
  • Blog
    • Latest Blogs
    • Featured Books
    • Blog Archive
  • Extras
    • Deleted Chapters
      • Choose Your Beginning
        • The Missing Introduction
        • Alternate Chapter 1
      • Ballerina Alla
      • Baubie Chapters
        • Celestial Tea and Essig Flaish
        • Celestial Tea and Mandelbrot
        • Celestial Tea and Poppy Seed Cookies
    • Recipes from Baubies
      • Recipes from Grandma Rae
        • Essig Flaish
        • Mandelbrot
        • Mohn Cookies
  • Press
    • Press Kit
    • In the Media
    • Reviews
  • Events
  • Contact
Font size: + –
Print
Bookmark |

April Book of the Month: A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles

Wednesday, 01 March 2017
Meryll
Highlighted Books
6387 Hits
0 Comments
April Book of the Month: A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles

Once upon a time, an evil king sentenced a kind Count to life imprisonment in a sprawling palace. Formerly ensconced in his plush and gilded quarters the Count was to the drafty garret. Nina, a spritely young girl, rescued the count bringing him back to life in his reduced surroundings. Alas, he couldn't rescue the grown-up Nina from her fate in the frozen tundra. But twice from the confines of his prison, the Count rescued Sophia, Nina's talented and beautiful daughter.

Who would have believed that a fairy tale could be set in Moscow during Stalin's brutal regime? Towles's tone is light and elegant, but he doesn't shy away from the shadows lurking outside the Hotel Metropol where the gentleman resides or, more accurately, has been imprisoned indefinitely by the Communists for writing an allegedly subversive poem. The hotel is a refuge as well as prison for Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, but the outside world blows into the lobby of the Metropol like a North wind when the doorman welcomes the outsiders across the hotel's threshold.

Towles deftly removes the count's privileges through his plot line and alerts the reader that facile stereotypes of an effete aristocrat, expert at arcane skills such as creating a seating plan for a formal dinner or knowing the correct flowers to send for each occasion, will be creatively deployed to further his survival and the survival of his friends. The count's impeccable aristocratic manners and mannered speech seem ill-suited for his life as a captive.The first indication that the count is not an innocent is the clever scene of the count stashing gold in the legs of his writing desk as he is forced to move from his suite to the servant's quarters under the roof. Towles manages a tour de force in setting virtually the entire novel within the walls of the Metropol Hotel without imprisoning the reader in claustrophobia.

One of the advantages of a novel is its ability to tell an important psychological or philosophical truth against a specific historical background. In Communist Russia from 1917 to 1989, individuals reacted to the rapid and frightening changes of life iwith a wide variety of responses. Some did attempt suicide like the Count but many persevered through famine, purges, war, and more purges. In Towles's novel, those who cope by forging friendships and demonstrating kindness are the "winners" and the heroes. They manage to carve a life overflowing with human warmth. Those who seek self-advancement and vengeance are the "losers" and the villains. Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov adapts and flourishes after his sentence of house arrest in 1922. As he did when he stashed his gold, the Count takes other measures to ensure his well-being. The key survival mechanism for the former member of the Jockey Club is building genuine friendships and relationships with staff and guests of the hotel. Adopting Sophia as his daughter is the pivotal moment in the Count's life, the moment when he assumes responsibility for another life and discovers his capacity for love and its power to sustain life.

You may wonder about the bizarre course of events and ask yourself—would a nobleman( belaya kost' ) return to Russia from Paris after the revolution? Were there people imprisoned in hotels? Could a little orphan girl be left when her parents were sent to Siberia? Was escape possible?

The reality is deftly presented in the non-fiction book I reviewed in November, Former People: The Final Days of the Russian Aristocracy by Douglas Smith( http://www.morejewishluck.com/easyblog/keep-up-with-vera-and-alisa-2/november-author-of-the-month-douglas-smith). By focusing on the Golitsyn and Sheremetev families, Smith offers a comprehensive and unromanticized portrait of the demise of Russia's nobility during the course of the Revolution. And it includes photographs. All aristocrats were labeled "former people" (byvšie lyudi) and all suffered at the hands of the Communists. There were instances of aristocrats fleeing to European capitals during the Revolution and its aftermath and there were some, like the fictional Count Alexander, who returned. Some were patriots and others returned to reunite with family members. Many of the former people were imprisoned and exiled, few were ignored as benevolently as Count Alexander. Some did live in straitened circumstances in a room or two of their palatial townhomes in Moscow or St. Petersburg. As life became more and more difficult, their connection to their palaces, their jewels, their stuff faded. For most it was books and portraits that they sought to save from the depredations of the marauders. Stalin was proven correct that the aristocracy could not become "new Soviet men" with their first loyalty to the State. Their loyalty was to their family. Smith also touches on the subject of possible escape and how dangerous it was for former people to speak to a diplomat or a journalist. It would be a short leap to an accusation of treason.

How Sophia became an orphan is a common story once Stalin's purges accelerated in 1936. In some cases both parents were sentenced to prison, exile, or death. In others, like Sophia's, one parent disappeared and the other parent went to uncover the fate of his or her partner. The child was left in "temporary care." Usually Stalin's bureaucrats confiscated not only the property of the accused, but also the children who were sent to State orphanages, a more effective place to indoctrinate children than a school. Children of "enemies of the State" bore the stain throughout their lives. Remaining alive and humane presented an enormous challenge for former people and their families.

Inspiration for this novel struck Amor Towles while staying at a Swiss luxury hotel. He realized some of the guests were residents. From there it was a short leap to plotting a novel with a protagonist under house arrest in a luxury hotel. The interview with NPR can be found at:

http://www.npr.org/2016/09/06/492434255/idea-for-gentleman-in-moscow-came-from-many-nights-in-luxury-hotels

A Gentleman in Moscow flows easily from page to page. For me it became even more compelling as the outside world seeps into the Hotel Metropol and the fairy tale became an allegory. The former person Alexander Ilyich Rostov transformed himself into a mensch, a very good person.

Tags:
Mensch Former People Book review A Gentleman in Moscow Amor Towles
Alisa's Birthday and the Siege of Leningrad
A Little March with Big Repercussions

About the author

Meryll

Meryll

  http://morejewishluck.com
View author's profile More posts from author
Meryll Levine Page is a retired high school history teacher with a special interest in women’s history. She taught extensively about the Soviet Union and its break-up. Currently she co-facilitates the Minneapolis Jewish Artists’ Lab.
Author's recent posts
Friday, 09 April 2021 Jewish on the Down Low
Sunday, 02 July 2017 Hack Attack
Sunday, 02 July 2017 July Book of the Month: Bloodlines by Neville Frankel
Sunday, 11 June 2017 Haunted by the Past; Family Pictures, Part II
Friday, 26 May 2017 What happened to Meryll's blogs?

Related Posts

November Author of the Month: Douglas Smith

Highlighted Books
 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Tuesday, 20 May 2025

Captcha Image

Recent Blogs

Meryll
Meryll
09 April 2021
Jewish on the Down Low
I snapped up the invitation to speak at a zoom meeting for the Jewish Affinity Group from Columbus School for Girls. Self-quarantining for almost a year has made me hungry to talk about Jewish Luck. It's certainly clear from the news that Vera and Alla's perceptions about the "New" Russia are just as relevant now as they were when Vera first encountered Putin in Leningrad.More than the intellectua...
Read More
Leslie
Leslie
07 February 2021
American Kompromat
What I learned from American Kompromat by Craig Unger (2021) Dutton: NYC has prompted me to write a blog. Trigger Warning: This book contains potentially distressing content that could trigger trauma that we have experienced regarding the previous US President. I whisper this mantra to myself: "We're safe now. He's gone. We're safe now." The purpose of this exercise is to reduce my blood pre...
Read More
Leslie
Leslie
31 January 2021
Alexey Navalny: Intrepid SuperHero of Russia
"Faster than a speeding bullet." .Organized anti-government rallies in 109 cities across Russia from jail for January 23 and January 30, 2021. Watch each weekend. "More powerful than a locomotive."  Able to make a miraculous recovery from Novichok poisoning on Aug. 20, 2020 after remaining in a coma for nearly a month. His is the only known case of survival of that strain of Novichok. "...
Read More

Invite Us To Speak

invite

We were featured speakers at Hadassah Brandeis Institute and Levy Summer Series. Our speaking engagements include JCCs, synagogues, libraries, book groups, retirement communities, schools, and organizations (e.g. ORT, Hadassah, and Women's League). References are available. 

Invite Us To Speak
 

Talk Review

"I was very fortunate to be able to hear Meryll and Leslie speak at a Hadassah event in Israel. Each of the ~50 participants really enjoyed the event because Meryll and Leslie were so engaging. While they had a natural rapport with the audience, you could also tell they had prepared well so they could connect with our particular group's interests. I learned a lot from listening to them, and I found their sisterly interaction unique and fun. If you want an enlightening and uplifting experience, attend one of their book talks."
Lisa Shimoni, Modiin Israel

Book Review

"Truly, you have written a story that makes accessible the reality of existence in Russia, through the eyes of individuals who lived through the various regimes and dictates.  It is fascinating and very well told.  As I read Vera and Alla's story, I learned more Russian history than I had known from a textbook.  That's a big deal, women!  You tell the tale with vivid detail and hook us on the two women and their stories, then weave in the history to illuminate their journeys. It is such a necessary book.  I am thrilled that the two of you collaborated, as I can see the uniqueness of your personalities come through in the stories, and that, too, makes the book a gem."
Margaret Leibfried, Danielson Group consultant

Buy the Book

Online:

Click here to order your copy of Jewish Luck: A True Story of Friendship, Deception, and Risky Business on Amazon.com.

The Kindle version is available here

In Stores:
cgb250
logo-sholom
Make a donation to Sholom Home and enjoy Jewish Luck at the same time. Jewish Luck is now available at the Sholom Home West gift store. Meryll and Leslie will donate 50% of the proceeds back to Sholom Home. Enjoy!

Tasting Torah

Nourish mind, body, and soul with Meryll's Tasting Torah, which will bring oneg (joy) and limmud (learning) to your Shabbat, broaden your culinary horizons, and draw your Shabbat guests closer together.

logo tasting torah

Highlighted Books

Meryll
Meryll
02 July 2017
July Book of the Month:  Bloodlines by Neville Frankel
July Book of the Month: Bloodlines by Neville Frankel
Leslie and I began writing Jewish Luck with an underlying question in our minds—what would life have...
Read More

Copyright © 2016 All Rights Reserved by More Jewish Luck

Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Login

Site created by LiveSites